- 96 Posts Started
- 1,755 Participant
- 1,851 Total Posts
I would have him over any of our forwards !
Nah, He is one of those United players they get from time to time that get carried by the rest of the team. Butt, P Neville, Gibson, Sharpe, Carrick, Richardson, Bellion, Kleberson, Manucho, Djemba Djemba, Obertan. Put those type of player in any other side and they look extremely average and soon disappear.
You dont half talk some shyte you.
P Neville would look extremely average in any other side? :silly:
Have you seen him for Everton? He’s been captain fantastic for the best part of ten years!!!
Wobble Wobble – dont like you very much.[/quote]
Just because Neville is a good “leader”.. doesn’t make him a great player.
He is far, far from being a great player – he’s just versatile.
The phrase “Jack of all trades, master of none” springs to mind.
I actually agree with the most part of Yosser’s post.
Welbeck isn’t a good player – how he can be considered international quality is beyond me.
Put it this way, if he was in our side – playing EXACTLY the same as he has for United in the past 12 months or so – he wouldn’t be in the England squad.
He gets picked because he’s a United player – and that automatically makes him worthy of an England call up (apparently).
Despite the fact he is a very average, bit-part player.[/quote]
TBH my post was just an impression of the girly dig he had at me earlier in the year.
No Phil Neville is no Christiano Ronaldo but I think if you ask any Evertonian they will consider him a great player and adds the sort of metal to a team that I dont think we have had since Cattermole left.
As for the rest :
Nicky Butt : 2002 World Cup – World class performance !
Sharpe – Quality player who unfortunately liked to party a bit too much and got him in trouble with Ferguson.
Carrick – Most underappreciated midfielder in the history of the PL and is a massive player for Man Utd and has been for years!
Bellion, Kleberson, Manucho, Djemba Djemba, Obertan – All these hardly got carried at united they were crap while they were at the club.
Putting Butt’s World Cup performance aside he might have a point on Nicky Butt, Richardson & Gibson.
But I would have both Richardson and Gibson here tomorrow given the choice.