Walton – we all wanted him back but now he isn’t keeping clean sheets every week he’s rubbish.
Burn – we all said it was superb business but now he’s not at his best he isn’t good enough at this level despite being our player of the year two years ago.
Kipre – has a mistake in him, but looks a good player.
James – class player.
Robinson – brilliant going forward but can’t defend.
Gibson – arguably the man of the match on day one, bossed the midfield. Got injured, came back and with the side no longer the same has struggled to make an impact.
Naismith – never a left back. Would like to see him where he is meant to be as he is probably one of the best crossers of a ball we have.
Windass – we all thought he was a top signing. Seems lazy at times but again not playing in his best position. Does look good in the #10 role.
Garner – 3rd choice striker who is experienced at this level. Seeing as we can’t afford Messi he will have to do.
McManaman – was unsure on this one at the time. Too hit and miss and can be a liability in defence. His lack of action in the first team suggests Cook doesn’t see enough in him.
Would I give him more cash? Probably, but it depends how much we are giving him. We won’t get 3 quality players with the Nick Powell money alone for example which everyone will expect him to do.
