I take it by the lack of response to this thread no one rates him, he’s always out on loan and when he’s played for WAFC scored a couple but never shone,good or crap I’m undecided.
Listen to what he said grumps he loves the club and he is desperate to make it here. Now we don’t have too many who are passionate about WAFC except the fans so hopefully he will go on to become a legend. Time will tell but I’ve just got that feeling that Cookie is gonna make things happen here and some players will relish playing for him.