- This topic has 13 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 9 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Toney brought down in box allegedly seconds before the greed leaguers go up and equalise.
Gutted but we’ll done lads. Not a lot can be done when officials do you like this.
Anyway that’s another match for us fans to see.
Typical BBC reporter though who said ‘Thats another match that Eddie Howe has to worry about’. So Paul Cook has nothing to play for BBC??Looking at the incident I would say the ref bottled it but Toney should have scored anyway. Another late miss by him.
If we need to take Grigg off all the time we need someone of his calibre to replace him or simply keep him on till the end.Slowing the footage down, I would say that their defender kicked Ivan’s standing foot from under him; therefore defo pen. Hey, we are little Wigan and we are used to this type of shit. It will never change :angry: :angry: :angry:
Ally it stinks and it’s wrong. Between the ref and linesman to both be so blind it’s unexplainable yet again. F’ing cheated.
It was a strange incident as Toney just went down and there didn’t look like anything untoward, I thought he must have slipped?
Heard someone say he got a push in the back but I didn’t see that. Will have to see on highlights later.
Nailed on pen IMO.Without any doubt.
He had gone round the side of the keeper, another yard and he wouldve rolled it in. Penalty and a straight red.
If he thought Toni dove, why didnt he book him then?
Two points:
If he had gone round the keeper on the other side and rolled it in, there would have been no penalty and no card, as there technically wouldn’t have been a foul. Just a goal, which Toney may have been better doing.
And two: There’s a difference between someone going down under a fair challenge, and diving. He could well have assumed he went down under a fair challenge. He can appeal for a penalty, but that doesn’t make it a dive.He’s gone down VERY easily in my opinion. Why he hasn’t just had the shot in the first place I don’t know.
Having watched the highlights back though, how good were some of Christian Walton’s saves?????
He’s gone down VERY easily in my opinion. Why he hasn’t just had the shot in the first place I don’t know.Having watched the highlights back though, how good were some of Christian Walton’s saves?????
Walton was superb Egg, possibly MOM along with Dan Burn.
Wright and co pundit on Motd rekon no pen .Zoomed in on their legs but the foul wasn’t a leg tangle it was a little nudge with his arm which took him out .Yes he went down too easily but Yes it absolutely was a penalty .
As Alan Shearer said about the scouse penalty, not every touch is a foul. He doesn’t push him or shove him he nudges him which he is entitled to do. Toney then decides to throw himself to the floor.
I always try and look at a decision like this and reverse it. How would I feel if that was given AGAINST us? I think i’d have been rather annoyed TBH.
Of course I could be wrong on the nudge by the letter of the law, but in my opinion he is entitled to do that.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
