- This topic has 8 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 10 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
As our resident ref I would be interested to hear you’re take on Mourinho,s view and subsequent rant about the penalty he says was not given. My view is both players made contact with the ball and it was the ball that brought Herrera down so never a penalty in the memory of man. A true 50-50 challenge and Michael Oliver was spot on with the decision. The one City could have been awarded was a lot more likely. How did you see it?.
Utd no pen. City pen. Everton pen.All three were down to cheating, going down like they had been shot and/or trying to con the ref!
Fuck the EFL
As our resident ref I would be interested to hear you’re take on Mourinho,s view and subsequent rant about the penalty he says was not given. My view is both players made contact with the ball and it was the ball that brought Herrera down so never a penalty in the memory of man. A true 50-50 challenge and Michael Oliver was spot on with the decision. The one City could have been awarded was a lot more likely. How did you see it?.It wasn’t a penalty & the ref got it spot on to book him for diving – my view of it yesterday is that Herrera knocked it past him & expected the challenge to come in, it didn’t so he stuck his left leg out & made contact with the defender & not the other way round
City should have had a penalty IMO if you;re talking about the one where some United defender grabbed a City player round the neck with his arm & pulled him to the floor.
You didn’t ask about the Everton one but someone else mentioned it so I’ll chuck my twopenneth in about that too – it was a penalty all day long. He pushed him in the back. Enough to knock him over? Possibly not, but enough to have made him lose control of the ball. Penalty & Klopp has made himself look like a right idiot with his attitude in the post match interviews that I’ve seen
As has Mourinho
The pundits on MOTD got it spot on yesterday with their comments about Klopp. He disrespected Everton by dropping Coutinho & Firminho to the bench and then tried to blame Everton’s tactics and the ref for his selection errors.
The mask has well and truly slipped off the “happy German’s” face now.
it was a penalty all day long. He pushed him in the back. Enough to knock him over? Possibly not, but enough to have made him lose control of the ball. [/quote]
What absolute garbage, ive been pushed harder by my 8 year old niece, no wonder the egg chasers take the piss!
Fuck the EFL
it was a penalty all day long. He pushed him in the back. Enough to knock him over? Possibly not, but enough to have made him lose control of the ball.What absolute garbage, ive been pushed harder by my 8 year old niece, no wonder the egg chasers take the piss![/quote]
Not all contact on a football pitch is a foul but a 2 handed shove in the back is. Every time. It was a penalty whether you feel the Everton guy made the most of it or not
As our resident ref I would be interested to hear you’re take on Mourinho,s view and subsequent rant about the penalty he says was not given. My view is both players made contact with the ball and it was the ball that brought Herrera down so never a penalty in the memory of man. A true 50-50 challenge and Michael Oliver was spot on with the decision. The one City could have been awarded was a lot more likely. How did you see it?.
It wasn’t a penalty & the ref got it spot on to book him for diving – my view of it yesterday is that Herrera knocked it past him & expected the challenge to come in, it didn’t so he stuck his left leg out & made contact with the defender & not the other way round
City should have had a penalty IMO if you;re talking about the one where some United defender grabbed a City player round the neck with his arm & pulled him to the floor.
You didn’t ask about the Everton one but someone else mentioned it so I’ll chuck my twopenneth in about that too – it was a penalty all day long. He pushed him in the back. Enough to knock him over? Possibly not, but enough to have made him lose control of the ball. Penalty & Klopp has made himself look like a right idiot with his attitude in the post match interviews that I’ve seen
As has Mourinho[/quote]
Have to agree with all of that Tylds.
The City one was ridiculous. Matic has two arms round him and then Herrera (who I hate as a player) throws him on the floor.
The Everton one is a foul on halfway and possibly even a yellow. You cant shove someone in the back like that.
Klopp and Jose have tried to deflect fr0m poor performances and results and have just made themselves look daft. Fergie was the master at it.
it was a penalty all day long. He pushed him in the back. Enough to knock him over? Possibly not, but enough to have made him lose control of the ball.What absolute garbage, ive been pushed harder by my 8 year old niece, no wonder the egg chasers take the piss![/quote]
The way Herrera goes down to get Walker booked is what annoys me as a fan of both sports. Jumps in the air, goes down and then does a backflip almost. Gets up, checks the players been booked and then carries off.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
