Giles Barnes

Forums Latics Crazy Forum Giles Barnes

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 24 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #18363
    alex_wiganAlex Whalley
    Player

      Does anybody remember this lad from Derby County?

      When they were in the prem he attracted huge interest from the likes of Villa, Spurs, City (before the big cash) + a few others.

      He is now a free agent and has been since around the summer period after being released by Derby. His career has been plagued by injuries and it looks to have ruined a good prospect in Barnes.

      He is still only 21, been training with Birmingham but has now gone to West Brom for a trial.

      Shame really, always thought he was a good player who could make a name for himself.

      #18364

      Not good enough really, looked good at Derby due to his shocking teammates. If West Brom have turned him down, I don’t think we should be signing him.

      #18365
      alex_wiganAlex Whalley
      Player
        Does anybody remember this lad from Derby County?

        When they were in the prem he attracted huge interest from the likes of Villa, Spurs, City (before the big cash) + a few others.

        He is now a free agent and has been since around the summer period after being released by Derby. His career has been plagued by injuries and it looks to have ruined a good prospect in Barnes.

        He is still only 21, been training with Birmingham but has now gone to West Brom for a trial.

        Shame really, always thought he was a good player who could make a name for himself.

        I am not for 1 minute saying we should sign him. I’ve just seen his name mentioned on sky sports new about going to West Brom training on trial and looked at his wiki page. I wouldn’t want us to sign an injury plagued player, we sold Jimmy B at the right time and look at him now! People were asking for him back here not long ago. No Thanks!

        #18366

        You mean the same injury prone Jimmy Bullard that broke the record for successive Latics appearances? He’s been plaqued by injuries since he left because of a recurring injury problem that he got playing for Fulham vs Newcastle. If he was at Wigan at the time, I doubt he would have got that injury.

        #18372
        If he was at Wigan at the time, I doubt he would have got that injury.

        How on earth do you justify that statement? :?

        #18381
        jamescJamesC
        Player

          If he was at Wigan at the time, I doubt he would have got that injury.

          How on earth do you justify that statement? :? [/quote]

          Because he wouldn’t have been playing in the game for fulham vs newcastle therefore parker couldnt have fell on his leg and snapped it. Simple really. He may have got an injury at some stage but it wouldnt have been that injury and its more than likely that parker wouldnt have fell on his leg. Either you are not very clever or your trying to cause an argument for arguments sake.

          #18385

          If he was at Wigan at the time, I doubt he would have got that injury.

          How on earth do you justify that statement? :? [/quote]

          Because he wouldn’t have been playing in the game for fulham vs newcastle therefore parker couldnt have fell on his leg and snapped it. Simple really. He may have got an injury at some stage but it wouldnt have been that injury and its more than likely that parker wouldnt have fell on his leg. Either you are not very clever or your trying to cause an argument for arguments sake.[/quote]

          Hang on a minute James, on the same basis, you might as well say that had he not signed for Wigan, you wouldn’t even be having this conversation!

          #18386
          jamescJamesC
          Player

            But he wouldn’t have got that injury had he not signed for Fulham

            #18390

            Correct, but also, had he been born a girl, he would not have been a footballer, and would also not have got the injury! It’s all down to circumstance. Leaving Wigan is as much to blame for the injury as his decision to get out of the bed that morning. It’s just a silly argument.

            #18394
            Because he wouldn’t have been playing in the game for fulham vs newcastle therefore parker couldnt have fell on his leg and snapped it. Simple really. He may have got an injury at some stage but it wouldnt have been that injury and its more than likely that parker wouldnt have fell on his leg. Either you are not very clever or your trying to cause an argument for arguments sake.

            First of all, who asked you?

            Secondly, don’t be an ar**. I can’t decide which is more annoying. You trying to be funny, pedantic or acting thick.

            #18395
            jamescJamesC
            Player
              Correct, but also, had he been born a girl, he would not have been a footballer, and would also not have got the injury! It’s all down to circumstance. Leaving Wigan is as much to blame for the injury as his decision to get out of the bed that morning. It’s just a silly argument.

              Not disagreeing with you, But the fact remains if he was at wigan that injury would not have happened.

              #18399

              Correct, but also, had he been born a girl, he would not have been a footballer, and would also not have got the injury! It’s all down to circumstance. Leaving Wigan is as much to blame for the injury as his decision to get out of the bed that morning. It’s just a silly argument.

              Not disagreeing with you, But the fact remains if he was at wigan that injury would not have happened.[/quote]

              Apart from the obvious possibility that he could have suffered the exact same injury playing for Wigan that very afternoon. He just wouldn’t have had to spend the night in Newcastle General.

              #18400
              jamescJamesC
              Player

                Correct, but also, had he been born a girl, he would not have been a footballer, and would also not have got the injury! It’s all down to circumstance. Leaving Wigan is as much to blame for the injury as his decision to get out of the bed that morning. It’s just a silly argument.

                Not disagreeing with you, But the fact remains if he was at wigan that injury would not have happened.[/quote]

                Apart from the obvious possibility that he could have suffered the exact same injury playing for Wigan that very afternoon. He just wouldn’t have had to spend the night in Newcastle General.[/quote]

                He couldnt have suffered the EXACT same injury, Parker couldn’t have fell on his leg as they wouldnt have been on the same pitch, he would have been paying slightly different due to the managers tactics etc etc, Another argument lost Griff I would just quit if I was you.

                #18403
                He couldnt have suffered the EXACT same injury, Parker couldn’t have fell on his leg as they wouldnt have been on the same pitch, he would have been paying slightly different due to the managers tactics etc etc, Another argument lost Griff I would just quit if I was you.

                Do you know what? You’re right. I’m crap at this. You win.

                :roll: :roll: :roll:

                #18405
                jamescJamesC
                Player

                  He couldnt have suffered the EXACT same injury, Parker couldn’t have fell on his leg as they wouldnt have been on the same pitch, he would have been paying slightly different due to the managers tactics etc etc, Another argument lost Griff I would just quit if I was you.

                  Do you know what? You’re right. I’m rubbish at this. You win.

                  :roll: :roll: :roll: [/quote]

                  Finally the truth comes out. :D

                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 24 total)
                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

                Forums Latics Crazy Forum Giles Barnes