ive seen it a few times and i still think it was a penalty
I’ve only seen it twice and I’m not sure, I’d want a pen if a Wigan player was brought down like that but I’d say it was a fair tackle if Titus made it, from the refs point of view I can see why he gave it, for me it’s decisions like this that make it essential that the ref should be able to go and look at the monitors that are already available next to the dugouts, the ball was out of play so he’d not be holding the game up.
What goes around comes around, I agree with that but I can’t see Alex McLeish asking for 2 points to be taken off Birmingham and 1 awarded to us.[/quote]
Spot on that… If you think about it, the player that committed the foul did play the ball, but then he completely took the player out when the ball was nowhere near him, nothing is saying that Agbonlahor couldn’t get to it afterwards. So for me it was a penalty.