Figueroa and Caldwell both played their part in the Great Escape last season. If you think Figueroa and Caldwell are equally bad, then you won’t expect any improvement if Caldwell comes in for Figueroa.
The defence has certainly been poor this season, but I would say that injuries have been the main cause of that. Figueroa, to his credit, has appeared in most games.
Martinez has converted Figueroa from a full-back into a centre-half/back three player. Who is going to replace him in the team? Will Wigan have to change their style too?
Wigan ended with a makeshift defence on Saturday, with a back four of Stam, Boyce, Scharner and Beausejour. What alternative is there?