I No match day on a Saturday

Forums Latics Crazy Forum I No match day on a Saturday

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 37 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #173114
    The EggThe Egg
    Chairman
    • 325 Posts Started
    • 6,432 Participant
    • 6,757 Total Posts

    Take away the likes of Aguero, Silva, De Bryune, Hazard, De Gea, Pogba, Salah, Mane, Firminio, Eriksen, Van Dijk.

    No one wants to take away the above players, just limit the amount that clubs are allowed to play in a match.[/quote]

    And you think all those players would hang around to sit on the bench?

    Robles
    Boyce
    Scharner
    Alcaraz
    Espinoza
    Kone
    Gomez

    Who do you drop from that? And that isn’t including McArthur, McCarthy or Maloney.

    #173115
    Goole Away 71Goole Away 71
    Player
    • 1 Posts Started
    • 235 Participant
    • 236 Total Posts

    Excellent point Horc but to make that even more workable clubs should be limited to three overseas players per squad.

    Now that would make sense and be a solution to a major problem within our game. Do you fancy a job at UEFA or FIFA. No…………….I thought not, you’re not corrupt enough.[/quote]
    It’s a massive problem in the game and the major contributor to why England have failed so miserably time after time.[/quote]

    So why did England fail so miserably when there weren’t overseas players in club squads?

    #173116
    donnys pageDonnys Page
    Player
    • 580 Posts Started
    • 4,791 Participant
    • 5,371 Total Posts

    Take away the likes of Aguero, Silva, De Bryune, Hazard, De Gea, Pogba, Salah, Mane, Firminio, Eriksen, Van Dijk.

    No one wants to take away the above players, just limit the amount that clubs are allowed to play in a match.[/quote]

    And you think all those players would hang around to sit on the bench?

    Robles
    Boyce
    Scharner
    Alcaraz
    Espinoza
    Kone
    Gomez

    Who do you drop from that? And that isn’t including McArthur, McCarthy or Maloney.[/quote]
    Most of them would be playing in their own countries and we would have English players playing in our sides again.

    #173117
    The EggThe Egg
    Chairman
    • 325 Posts Started
    • 6,432 Participant
    • 6,757 Total Posts

    Exactly Goole.

    And come on Donny. Who would you drop from our FA Cup XI that had ONE English player in it.

    #173118
    horchorc
    Manager
    • 177 Posts Started
    • 5,130 Participant
    • 5,307 Total Posts

    Take away the likes of Aguero, Silva, De Bryune, Hazard, De Gea, Pogba, Salah, Mane, Firminio, Eriksen, Van Dijk.

    No one wants to take away the above players, just limit the amount that clubs are allowed to play in a match.[/quote]

    And you think all those players would hang around to sit on the bench?

    Robles
    Boyce
    Scharner
    Alcaraz
    Espinoza
    Kone
    Gomez

    Who do you drop from that? And that isn’t including McArthur, McCarthy or Maloney.[/quote]

    Robles, Alcaraz, Espinosa, Scharner and Kone are great examples of players who were no better than English or British counterparts, just cheaper options, and to be honest would not replace any of the players in their positions in our present squad.
    Boyce and Gomez were a different class though, and would probably get into any squad we have ever had.
    As for the Scottih lads, they are British, so would be allowed in the squads anyway.

    #173119
    The EggThe Egg
    Chairman
    • 325 Posts Started
    • 6,432 Participant
    • 6,757 Total Posts

    How do Scottish lads help England?

    Paul Scharner is definitely better than Chey Dunkley or Cedric Kipre and Antolin Alcaraz is better than them 3 and Dan Burn.

    #173120
    Super Stuart BarlowSuper Stuart Barlow
    Player
    • 30 Posts Started
    • 1,722 Participant
    • 1,752 Total Posts

    And you’ll be the first to moan when we lose a game because we’re missing 2 or 3 players or when we get relegated because we are getting stuffed every week as we can only play English lads.

    There is no reason why homegrown players can’t be as good if they get the chance and if the coaching etc is good enough.[/quote]

    They haven’t been for the past 50 years.

    #173121
    Super Stuart BarlowSuper Stuart Barlow
    Player
    • 30 Posts Started
    • 1,722 Participant
    • 1,752 Total Posts

    Take away the likes of Aguero, Silva, De Bryune, Hazard, De Gea, Pogba, Salah, Mane, Firminio, Eriksen, Van Dijk.

    No one wants to take away the above players, just limit the amount that clubs are allowed to play in a match.[/quote]

    And you think all those players would hang around to sit on the bench?

    Robles
    Boyce
    Scharner
    Alcaraz
    Espinoza
    Kone
    Gomez

    Who do you drop from that? And that isn’t including McArthur, McCarthy or Maloney.[/quote]

    And how long do we last in the prem possibly without:

    De Zeeuw
    Boyce
    Al Habsi
    Palacios
    Valencia
    Zaki
    N’Zogbia
    Figueroa
    Melchiot
    Rodallega
    Gomez

    #173122
    horchorc
    Manager
    • 177 Posts Started
    • 5,130 Participant
    • 5,307 Total Posts
    How do Scottish lads help England?

    Paul Scharner is definitely better than Chey Dunkley or Cedric Kipre and Antolin Alcaraz is better than them 3 and Dan Burn.

    #173123
    horchorc
    Manager
    • 177 Posts Started
    • 5,130 Participant
    • 5,307 Total Posts
    Exactly Goole.

    And come on Donny. Who would you drop from our FA Cup XI that had ONE English player in it.

    We beat a far stronger Man City team in last seasons FA Cup with English players in the positions of some the ones you mentioned earlier.

    2013 – Robles
    2017 – Walton

    2013 – Espinosa
    2017 – Jacobs

    2013 – Alcaraz
    2017 – Burn

    2013 – Scharner
    2017 – Powell

    2013 – Kone
    2017 – Grigg

    #173124
    Super Stuart BarlowSuper Stuart Barlow
    Player
    • 30 Posts Started
    • 1,722 Participant
    • 1,752 Total Posts

    You do know that none of those players played for us then and Grigg would be as useful to the England side as Kone would.

    #173125
    muttywhitedogmuttywhitedog
    Player
    • 33 Posts Started
    • 1,496 Participant
    • 1,529 Total Posts
    If a team has three or more England internationals picked for a game, then okay, that club should be able to postpone a game.
    Postponing games because foreign nationals are picked for their country should not be permitted. Squads are big enough these days, and if it had an impact on teams being below par, it might just make them put more effort into producing English players instead of buying all all the foreign players.

    I seem to recall Latics calling a game off last season after their 3rd choice goalkeeper had been picked for Wales U21s.

    #173126
    donnys pageDonnys Page
    Player
    • 580 Posts Started
    • 4,791 Participant
    • 5,371 Total Posts
    Exactly Goole.

    And come on Donny. Who would you drop from our FA Cup XI that had ONE English player in it.

    Thats a different situation. That none English FA Cup winning side was a side playing within the rules of then and now. The three overseas players per squad is a totally hypothetical idea which could be brought in in the future to bring on English football. Totally unrelated to any side we have now or in the past. Its not unreasnable to want to limit clubs to how many overseas players they have I dont think. Loan players too in and outcould also be limited to that same number.

    #173127
    donnys pageDonnys Page
    Player
    • 580 Posts Started
    • 4,791 Participant
    • 5,371 Total Posts

    If a team has three or more England internationals picked for a game, then okay, that club should be able to postpone a game.
    Postponing games because foreign nationals are picked for their country should not be permitted. Squads are big enough these days, and if it had an impact on teams being below par, it might just make them put more effort into producing English players instead of buying all all the foreign players.

    I seem to recall Latics calling a game off last season after their 3rd choice goalkeeper had been picked for Wales U21s.[/quote]
    I know and totally wrong. Not sure but that may have been the one to give the squad a break where some players had an early season holiday.

    #173128
    donnys pageDonnys Page
    Player
    • 580 Posts Started
    • 4,791 Participant
    • 5,371 Total Posts

    If a team has three or more England internationals picked for a game, then okay, that club should be able to postpone a game.
    Postponing games because foreign nationals are picked for their country should not be permitted. Squads are big enough these days, and if it had an impact on teams being below par, it might just make them put more effort into producing English players instead of buying all all the foreign players.

    I seem to recall Latics calling a game off last season after their 3rd choice goalkeeper had been picked for Wales U21s.[/quote]
    I know and totally wrong. Not sure but that may have been the one to give the squad a break where some players had an early season holiday.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 37 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Forums Latics Crazy Forum I No match day on a Saturday