Blind Faith versus Destructive Criticism

Forums Latics Crazy Forum Blind Faith versus Destructive Criticism

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 35 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #104663
    filmossfilmoss
    Player

      My reply was concise and to the point. Why should we settle for stagnation just because we came from the depths of lower league football. Piemons riposte was indeed heartfelt and sincere but he did indeed admit to having blind faith and whilst some fans are just grateful to be where we are now regardless of position or state of squad there are some of us JCL’s and stalwarts alike who would like a little bit more from our players. I happen to think that we have enough talent in the squad to survive but the right balance has not been found yet and that is down to the manager to work the oracle with what he has.This thread was not intended as a wind up but to point out that even big clubs like Liverpool have very similar rifts amongst their fans. There are fans on here who vent their spleen at crap performances only to be told by others to stop moaning and look how far we have come and other old chestnut sayings ! I have never been vitriolic in my posts but just because I have only been watching for 10 years doesn’t mean that I cant have an opinion or point out evidence of underachieving by certain players. Back to the never rest on your laurels,if you didn’t understand the adage then fine but don’t try and make out that I’m some sort of idiot. Nothing wrong at all wanting progression when it is a feasible goal but to be content for the sake of it due to history and the size of the club is counter-productive in my eyes ! 8 seasons in the Prem and we are still the whipping boys ! Whilst some of the old guard are happy with their lot some of us newer editions are more eager to properly establish ourselves in the top tier of English football, properly being the operative word ! We need to carry on building the fanbase for the future of the club and staying in the Prem and doing well in the Prem will indeed bring new fans,just accepting whatever happens because you support the team and getting mad with fans who are frustrated at the shite they are watching does not make you a better supporter. I will be there still if we go down but many wont and even though you will still be happy with your lot, your acceptance of how small we are and how far we have come etc will not fill the clubs coffers with much needed funds from fans and tv deals. I think the fans who want more success are the fans that will see this club prosper and the next generation of fans that come in will be like minded I hope !

      Paragraphs dear boy paragraphs :whistle: :whistle:[/quote]

      Constructive reply as usual !

      #104665
      jrfatfanjrfatfan
      Player
        I just want certain players who have the ability to put more effort in and if they cant be bothered sometimes then neither can I. They are on damn good money and are paid to perform to the best of their respective abilities, they are for want of a better word investments to the club and as a fan who would like to see us be more successful I would like to see such investments come to fruition, no crime in that !

        There’s no harm in that at all Fil, I hope it all works out for you.

        From Matlock to ManU
        What a journey!

        #104669

        Hang on. Am I missing something here?

        We’ve been spanked 4-0 loads of times and under every manager who has managed us in the Premier League, and we currently lie in a better league position than we have been at the this stage of the season for the past two years. We are in the quarter finals of the FA Cup, and have made a profit for the first time since God-knows-when.

        But if you read some of the comments on this board over the past week you’d think we were rock bottom, out of the cups at the first attempt as usual, with a club in turmoil, and suffering four goal thumpings every week.

        I think some people need to take a reality check.

        What sort of progress are people expecting? I’ll admit, after the ending to last season, I expected us to be doing better than we are currently, but that was probably because I was still riding the wave when this season kicked off.

        In reality, we’re still the club with the smallest fanbase; the lowest income; probably the least amount of global appeal.

        So how well should we be doing? (Serious answers only)

        #104677
        filmossfilmoss
        Player

          Quote…What sort of progress are people expecting? I’ll admit, after the ending to last season, I expected us to be doing better than we are currently, but that was probably because I was still riding the wave when this season kicked off.
          My own sentiments re the expecting to do better after the run of last season and this is my point, why haven’t we ? Certain players are underachieving and by mentioning that fact does not mean you are a moaning bastard which is what I get off certain people ! There is no reason ( Injuries apart ) why we couldn’t have at least maintained the form of ‘the run’ as it is called these days but for various reasons we haven’t have we.I guess I just get frustrated about the footy more than some but that doesn’t mean I am a moaning JCL. I actually as you may well know want further success !

          #104678
          Quote…What sort of progress are people expecting? I’ll admit, after the ending to last season, I expected us to be doing better than we are currently, but that was probably because I was still riding the wave when this season kicked off.
          My own sentiments re the expecting to do better after the run of last season and this is my point, why haven’t we ? Certain players are underachieving and by mentioning that fact does not mean you are a moaning bastard which is what I get off certain people ! There is no reason ( Injuries apart ) why we couldn’t have at least maintained the form of ‘the run’ as it is called these days but for various reasons we haven’t have we.I guess I just get frustrated about the footy more than some but that doesn’t mean I am a moaning JCL. I actually as you may well know want further success !

          No idea why we haven’t kicked on from last season.

          I don’t think it’s anything to do with having the tactics sussed out as we’ve looked good going forwards on numerous occasions this season, but we’ve been woeful at the back and that has nullified it.

          By rights, maybe we shouldn’t have gone on that run last season, and because we did, it just filled people with false hope.

          My expectations were for a comfortable 17th to 10th finish – and I think that’s the best we can ever really be expecting to achieve.

          #104680
          bickymonbickymon
          Player

            one reason we did not kick on was probably due to injuries and not really strengthening as we should have
            but my darkside says
            fooking whelan penny pinching owd cnut selling the cream and bringing in shyte over last few years
            got us in this mess
            much rather have stayed at springfield great 3000 fans and lower league football
            and more wins at home to celebrate and no jcl from salford and so on

            #104681
            Anonymous

              My main gripe is , there’s one or two players who under perform week in week out but still retain their starting position regardless and that’s just not me saying it, I hear the same names criticised at nearly every game I go.

              I personally think he could do with an older head at his side say like a Dave Bassett type of figure , I’m not saying him but someone of that ilk who’s been around around the block and might be able give a different perspective on a match. He can’t take advise from Graeme Jones as he’s to busy on BUBBLE WORLDS on his IPAD (heard he’s clocked it).

              Two heads are better than one.

              #104684
              bickymonbickymon
              Player

                cant see it to be honest ( two heads better than one )
                some folk on here would just argue with themselves all the time

                #104685
                filmossfilmoss
                Player

                  My main bugbear is the back line and I would like to know what the defence coach gets paid for because whoever it is just isn’t cutting it for me ! This was what he said 18 months ago after one particular game…Copy and paste job !

                  “What change is required must come from within the players themselves, he believes.

                  “We know what we have to do. We have been through this many times and it is a moment to be all together and face adversity,” he added.

                  “We are brave. We are a football club who base their way to win on a very clear group of concepts and we will continue doing that.

                  “But it is important we find that very good individual level of performance because we cannot afford to have two or three players not performing on the pitch.

                  “That has happened too many times unconsciously for many different reason and that is what we have to address.

                  “But it is not about being hard [on the players]. We all need to be demanding. Overall the players in their careers don’t deserve to be in a bad run of results but it is not about blaming people.

                  “We need to find our best moment of form individually and that is down to demands.”

                  Has anything changed ? Deja vu ! Somebody somewhere needs to put their foot down and start whipping them into shape because there are too many errors week in week out from certain players !

                  #104689
                  SammySammy
                  Player
                    My main bugbear is the back line and I would like to know what the defence coach gets paid for because whoever it is just isn’t cutting it for me !

                    Has anything changed ? Deja vu ! Somebody somewhere needs to put their foot down and start whipping them into shape because there are too many errors week in week out from certain players !

                    Maybe you’re just the man for the job. You should get yourself down there and bang on Martinez’s door. It must pay better than window cleaning and even allowing for the pressure of club’s current league position it can’t be any more stressful. It might just cheer you up a bit which would be an added bonus for us all on here?

                    #104691
                    no jcl from salford

                    Go on then i’ll bite.

                    1.)What makes me a JCL or makes you assume I wasnt at Springfield Park?

                    2.)What makes you think if we were still in the lower leagues or end up back in the lower leagues I wont a.) be there or b.) enjoy it just as much if not more than you?

                    3.)Just because you have been supporting the club a number of years doesnt make your opinion any more valid than any one elses on here.

                    If anything I would say your hackneyed views on the club are out of date for the modern game old timer.

                    #104693
                    jimmycjimmyc
                    Player

                      My main bugbear is the back line and I would like to know what the defence coach gets paid for because whoever it is just isn’t cutting it for me !

                      Has anything changed ? Deja vu ! Somebody somewhere needs to put their foot down and start whipping them into shape because there are too many errors week in week out from certain players !

                      Maybe you’re just the man for the job. You should get yourself down there and bang on Martinez’s door. It must pay better than window cleaning and even allowing for the pressure of club’s current league position it can’t be any more stressful. It might just cheer you up a bit which would be an added bonus for us all on here?[/quote]

                      Speak for yourself Sammy, although this post is not to the liking of some i think it is well constructed. That’s what a forum is for to discuss football and where people can voice their opinions.

                      #104694
                      bickymonbickymon
                      Player

                        no offence intended salford just wanted to see how fast you responded
                        actually i did know some from salford that used to drink in supporters club at springfield years ago now like

                        #104698
                        no offence intended salford just wanted to see how fast you responded
                        actually i did know some from salford that used to drink in supporters club at springfield years ago now like

                        Offence taken :(

                        #104715
                        SammySammy
                        Player

                          My main bugbear is the back line and I would like to know what the defence coach gets paid for because whoever it is just isn’t cutting it for me !

                          Has anything changed ? Deja vu ! Somebody somewhere needs to put their foot down and start whipping them into shape because there are too many errors week in week out from certain players !

                          Maybe you’re just the man for the job. You should get yourself down there and bang on Martinez’s door. It must pay better than window cleaning and even allowing for the pressure of club’s current league position it can’t be any more stressful. It might just cheer you up a bit which would be an added bonus for us all on here?[/quote]

                          Speak for yourself Sammy, although this post is not to the liking of some i think it is well constructed. That’s what a forum is for to discuss football and where people can voice their opinions.[/quote]
                          Firstly James, I wasn’t speaking for anyone else other than myself and neither did my post suggest otherwise.
                          I’ve come to the conclusion that filmoss is a miserable, pessimistic sourpuss who enjoys telling everyone how poor a team we have. Now, I’ve never met filmoss so I might be wrong but until I do, and I’m not losing sleep over it, I’ll stick to that opinion. You mentioned his post was well constructed but most of it is a quote by, I presume, Martinez from 18 months ago, but it could be the defence coach. Not particularly well constructed there then!
                          I suggested to filmoss that he might be the very man to put his foot down and whip them into shape seeing as it is quite obvious to him that this is the reason for our defensive frailties this season.
                          People watch the team they supposedly support for 90 minutes – less if you’re filmoss – maybe every two weeks and think they know better than the manager and his staff who work with the players every day.

                        Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 35 total)
                        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

                        Forums Latics Crazy Forum Blind Faith versus Destructive Criticism