Wigan. Has it had a sport revolution?

Forums Latics Crazy Forum Wigan. Has it had a sport revolution?

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #12829
    walker 93Josh Walker
    Player

      Im sure as many of you may very well know that Wigan has had a fine line between its football and rugby side, but which sport is dominant today ? Sure, Wigan Wariors may have very well dominated the town but with the success of Wigan Athletic over the years our fan base has shot up to the point that our attendences are over Wigan Warriors attendences. It may seem pretty obvious using the facts of our attendences but please i’d like to hear what everyone else thinks on the issue. Personally I think this towns turned blue and Wigan is domintated by Latics, and I can be really offensive on the subject towards the rugby side of Wigan but im being sensible :D Also lets not forget the other sports that have brought success to the town :)

      #12832
      fazfaz
      Player

        Whilst i know i shouldnt take the bait, i think youll find Wigan has always been a football town that has a top Rugby League team and now has a top football team for its people. However you really should be talking about Wigan as a sporting town as we have had success in a variety of sports including football, rugby, athletics, boxing, swimming and wrestling.

        #12833

        Im sure you will find lots of positive feedback about rugby league on here.

        #12846
        steste
        Player
          Whilst i know i shouldnt take the bait, i think youll find Wigan has always been a football town that has a top Rugby League team and now has a top football team for its people. However you really should be talking about Wigan as a sporting town as we have had success in a variety of sports including football, rugby, athletics, boxing, swimming and wrestling.

          thats a good point mate

          #12848
          walker 93Josh Walker
          Player
            Whilst i know i shouldnt take the bait, i think youll find Wigan has always been a football town that has a top Rugby League team and now has a top football team for its people. However you really should be talking about Wigan as a sporting town as we have had success in a variety of sports including football, rugby, athletics, boxing, swimming and wrestling.

            Yeah your right but im just focusing on two of them :) The one i love and the one i hate

            #12849
            walker 93Josh Walker
            Player
              Im sure you will find lots of positive feedback about rugby league on here.

              is that sarcasm ? :|

              #12859
              Well it would appear that Dave Whelan does not agree with you. When Wigan Athletic start to produce local players who are International standard then you may have a point.

              After all Scunthorpe have done it in the past.

              So if Dave Whelan says it isn’t so, it must be right eh?

              Give the lad some credit. He said the town WAS dominated by rugby, but IS NOW dominated by football.

              Interest in the Latics started to grow noticably ten years ago. Hardly enough time to develop international players is it? So, it’s not exactly a yardstick as to how football orientated the town has become.

              You see a lot more football (not just Wigan) shirts on Wigan kids than you do rugby shirts these days.

              Incidentally, what the f*ck have Scunthorpe got to do with anything?

              #12861

              Hmm Ian Botham played for Scunthorpe but to my knowledge there has never been a major international sports star from that particular town. Kevin Keegan was born in Donny if that helps our fat fingered egg chasing lurker

              I don’t really understand why there should be so much pride in Wigan producing so many international rugby league players, there aren’t really internationals at all. You can only really call yourself an international if your sport is played internationally and rugby league is only taken seriously in 3 or 4 countries. Can you really call it a World Cup when 99% of the world doesn’t play it? It’s like saying the Spanish are world champion bullfighters or Ireland produces the best Gaelic footballers. The Great Britain team don’t really represent GB either, they represent the hand ful of towns who bother to play the game. When noone else plays it, the sentiment is quite meaningless. I mean, why would somewhere like Birmingham or Newcastle produce international RL Stars when they don’t even play the game? Where else other than Wigan, St Helens, Warrington Hull Bradford or Leeds would a RL player come from? They barely play it anywhere else

              The cheese rollers in Gloucestershire will be claiming to be international cheese rollers next :roll:

              #12910
              walker 93Josh Walker
              Player
                Well it would appear that Dave Whelan does not agree with you. When Wigan Athletic start to produce local players who are International standard then you may have a point.

                After all Scunthorpe have done it in the past.

                Mate you don’t see the point im trying to make, its like standishwalker said. These days you can walk the streets of Wigan and you see more Wigan Athletic shirts, trackies, hats etc. than those of Wigan Warriors + our attendences are higher. I am not commenting on the teams themselves but the fan bases within Wigan.

                But please if you have evidence against this and what im saying about our town please throw it at me :) … and what do you mean by Scuthorpe and all that ?

                #12916

                Im sure you will find lots of positive feedback about rugby league on here.

                is that sarcasm ? :| [/quote]
                No mate, theres lots of positive comments made on here bout egg.

                #12918
                Hmm Ian Botham played for Scunthorpe but to my knowledge there has never been a major international sports star from that particular town. Kevin Keegan was born in Donny if that helps our fat fingered egg chasing lurker

                I don’t really understand why there should be so much pride in Wigan producing so many international rugby league players, there aren’t really internationals at all. You can only really call yourself an international if your sport is played internationally and rugby league is only taken seriously in 3 or 4 countries. Can you really call it a World Cup when 99% of the world doesn’t play it? It’s like saying the Spanish are world champion bullfighters or Ireland produces the best Gaelic footballers. The Great Britain team don’t really represent GB either, they represent the hand ful of towns who bother to play the game. When noone else plays it, the sentiment is quite meaningless. I mean, why would somewhere like Birmingham or Newcastle produce international RL Stars when they don’t even play the game? Where else other than Wigan, St Helens, Warrington Hull Bradford or Leeds would a RL player come from? They barely play it anywhere else

                The cheese rollers in Gloucestershire will be claiming to be international cheese rollers next :roll:

                I think Rogues was talking about players who played for Scunny – he never said “born”. Ray Clemence also played for Scunthorpe.

                Small steps. At the moment, you have nobody in your first team that is a product of your youth system/academy (Do you have one?), so before you develop an international, how about developing a bog-standard premiership footballer.

                #12919

                We have a youth system but no academy (as i’m sure you actually know anyway, but i’ll houmour you…….), the three previous managers didnt see the importance, and didnt actually want one, in having a fully setup academy. And to be honest i agree with them.

                #12921

                Hmm Ian Botham played for Scunthorpe but to my knowledge there has never been a major international sports star from that particular town. Kevin Keegan was born in Donny if that helps our fat fingered egg chasing lurker

                I don’t really understand why there should be so much pride in Wigan producing so many international rugby league players, there aren’t really internationals at all. You can only really call yourself an international if your sport is played internationally and rugby league is only taken seriously in 3 or 4 countries. Can you really call it a World Cup when 99% of the world doesn’t play it? It’s like saying the Spanish are world champion bullfighters or Ireland produces the best Gaelic footballers. The Great Britain team don’t really represent GB either, they represent the hand ful of towns who bother to play the game. When noone else plays it, the sentiment is quite meaningless. I mean, why would somewhere like Birmingham or Newcastle produce international RL Stars when they don’t even play the game? Where else other than Wigan, St Helens, Warrington Hull Bradford or Leeds would a RL player come from? They barely play it anywhere else

                The cheese rollers in Gloucestershire will be claiming to be international cheese rollers next :roll:

                I think Rogues was talking about players who played for Scunny – he never said “born”. Ray Clemence also played for Scunthorpe.

                Small steps. At the moment, you have nobody in your first team that is a product of your youth system/academy (Do you have one?), so before you develop an international, how about developing a bog-standard premiership footballer.[/quote]

                We have recently developed a ‘bog standard’ player. He is called Leighton Baines. (Yes, he is a Liverpool born lad, but under the Scunthorpe/Clemence Law, he qualifies)

                Before that we have had Peter Atherton, Warren Aspinall, and Gary Walsh. All local lads who started their careers at Wigan, and who all played in the top division.

                In a town where Rugby League has always been rammed down your thoat at schools until recently, we’re lucky to have produced any local talent at all. Now more and more kids would rather play football than Rugby League(it’s the sexy global sport compared to poor man’s rugby that is played professionally in only four countries), and Wigan schools are finally encouraging kids to play the sport.

                Look in the local papers: Wigan Athletic players visiting the local schools. Didn’t happen as much ten years ago, as to be honest, few of the kids would have recognised any of the players. Now it’s different. Which couple of players would most of the kids rather meet? Mario Melchiot, the former Dutch International who played for Chelsea, Paul Scharner – the Austrian International footballer, or Pat Richards and Sam Tomkins? (both of which are househole names, as long as your house is in New South Wales or the M62 corridor)

                Now it is being pushed at schools, we will produce good footballers in the future, as we’ve produced some of the country’s best Rugby League players, Rugby Union players, swimmers and athletes.

                #12942
                We have recently developed a ‘bog standard’ player. He is called Leighton Baines. (Yes, he is a Liverpool born lad, but under the Scunthorpe/Clemence Law, he qualifies)

                Before that we have had Peter Atherton, Warren Aspinall, and Gary Walsh. All local lads who started their careers at Wigan, and who all played in the top division.

                Ok, so in the last 20 years you have produced one player. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’m pretty sure Gary Walsh was a product of the Man Utd academy, as I remember playing cricket against him for Poolstock back in the 80s, and being utterly amazed to see him in goal for Man Utd a few years later.

                Its now 5 years since Wigan entered the premiership, and 7 years since you entered the Championship, and became a more established football club. Where are the Wigan kids that were talented footballers as 10 and 11 year olds in 2003? I dont see them in any other top flight side.

                I asked in an earlier thread about home-grown players, and the responses I got (apart from the irrelevent rugby-related ones) suggested to me that you have no talented up and coming youngsters, and no half-decent players out on loan at other clubs to gain experience.

                You say you dont have an academy. Once upon a time Newcastle didnt even have a reserve side, and look at the sh-it they are in. Leeds also had the “We can always buy players” approach too. It only lasts for so long with that approach, then it all comes tumbling down like a house of cards.

                As a Wiganer, I would like you to do well, however I am realistic and know that if a foundation is laid properly, the house will eventually come crashing down. Your club needs to start developing players from scratch rather than buying imports and flogging them on at a profit, as for every jewel, there’ll be half a dozen turds.

                #12945

                As a Wiganer, I would like you to do well, however I am realistic and know that if a foundation is laid properly, the house will eventually come crashing down. Your club needs to start developing players from scratch rather than buying imports and flogging them on at a profit, as for every jewel, there’ll be half a dozen turds.

                [/quote]

                This bit may well be true (apart from the bit highlighted in bold which makes no sense whatsoever) and since Roberto has arrived he has been looking at improving the youth set up and bringing in a younger breed of player and has bought some young Spanish players into the youth set up. Bringing across young foreign lads doesn’t appear to have done Mr Wenger much harm. You’ll have to speak to the chairman about why we don’t have a youth academy, the £40k a week saved on Marlon King’s wages could probably fund one. Perhaps you’d like to ask him to satisfy your obsessive interest in all things Wigan Athletic and when you get an answer, let us all know?

                I don’t really get your point about Internationals – as I said and you ignored, the whole country plays football and Wigan isn’t even one of the biggest 100 towns in the country to expect it to churn out internationals isn’t realistic. There’s a few players knocking around, Leon Osman, Andy Griffin, Chris Porter, you might be able to get a decent League One or Two outfit from Wigan based lads, which for the size of the town is about right. As for kids coming through, many of my mates grew up going to John Fisher in the early to mid 80s and the trouble is that the rugby league mafia simply wouldnt let kids play football, which is a terrible shame as lots of lads I know are handy footballers but were actively prevented from playing at school by maurice and his mates and fascist pe teachers. Encouraging kids to be good at a sport that encourages physical violence and probably is about as popular as Lacrosse or Curling on the national and international stage is a bit perverse in my view.

                Don’t know whether it’s changed since in schools but as I said it’s not like rugby league where the majority of the country isn’t interested in it, there are many millions of people playing football up and down the country compared to a few thousand playing RL. Maybe now that the heavy local bias towards RL is receding this will be reflected in the town producing more footballers, and this should be enncouraged as top footballers are skilful, athletic and generate enormous wealth and pride for the community and national coverage and interest.
                I don’t know how we’re expected to be so proud that we have that local lads represent the ‘country’ in a game which 95% of the country ignores. Football is competitive and there are a couple of million kids leaving school every year across the country aspiring of playing football for a living, compared to a few hundred from pit towns in the north who aspire to play rugby league.

                Football is a global game, the Premier League has global attraction and there are kids and young players all over South America now looking at our football club as an exciting prospect to develop their careers and local kids seek to emulate their idols, and maybe will do over time. Villareal in Spain have been doing it years, offering Latin American kids a way into La Liga and also picking up the scraps off the bigger clubs and offering them first team football and it’s not done them any harm.

              Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 22 total)
              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

              Forums Latics Crazy Forum Wigan. Has it had a sport revolution?