- This topic has 50 replies, 16 voices, and was last updated 11 years ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Aye. Bloody rubbish Scharner. That’s the second time we have lost in the eleven games since you came back. First Liverpool now the bloody champions on their ground. And you have helped us get to Wembley conceding one goal in the three ties you have played in. Bugger off back to Germany!
Aye. Bloody rubbish Scharner. That’s the second time we have lost in the eleven games since you came back. First Liverpool now the bloody champions on their ground. And you have helped us get to Wembley conceding one goal in the three ties you have played in. Bugger off back to Germany!Do you work in HR Roy? That’s about spot on, post it.
Another sterling footballing contribution from Cockneylatic’s wannabe funny man JohnDoe…
No he didn’t do everything perfect but he made some game saving tackles.
No way back for Caldwell I am afraid.
There was no intended humour in my post Salford, I don’t think it’s funny, in my opinion he’s rubbish and cost us a point, you think he’s great and made game saving tackles (even though we lost?) all opinions my friend.[/quote]
If we concentrated on results and not performance Martinez would of been sacked in his first season.
Thank god the officials running the club have the perspective to see beyond a result.
Europe here we come!!!![/quote]
I do see beyond a result Salford, it was a really good performance tonight, deserved something from the game no doubt about it, I don’t think Scharner just had a bad game though, I just think he’s poor, Saturday was the same, he’s not a very good player and there’s a good chance that silva will tear him a new one at wembley, not good enough in my book, should have left him where he was.[/quote]
I can respect a footballing argument when I see one as everyone is entitled to their opinion!
None the less I completely disagree (shock horror)
The alternative is Caldwell who I have to reluctantly say is not up to the job at all.
The mobility of Scharner and Figroll allows Alcaraz to sit deep and be the ball stopper which is IMO when we see the best of him!
So we need to find a better alternative, I agree, Caldwell is slower than a tax rebate, but Scharner is not up to scratch either, just because he’s the best option doesn’t mean he’s not beyond criticism.
He is cover for Ramis simple as ! He has been off key the last couple of games though, I don’t think many could deny that !
Scharner was caught ball watching just before Tevez received the ball that lead to the goal,you just cant give the likes of Tevez 3 yrd on the edge of our box. Why does he always feel the need to go to ground at every opportunity ?
Sharner is our best centre half. Look at the results since he has started playing and Caldwell hasn’t. Yeah he gets turned easily at times but makes up for it with his tackles.
Clueless!!!!!
Sharner is our best centre half. Look at the results since he has started playing and Caldwell hasn’t. Yeah he gets turned easily at times but makes up for it with his tackles.Clueless!!!!!
I don’t think he can be blamed for the defeat tonight, but I would argue that Alcaraz is our best centre half.
Scharner for me was indeed our weakest link tonight and constantly had me squirming in my seat ! I had a gut feeling that he would have a hand in any goals that we conceded and unfortunately I wasn’t wrong ! Great performance tonight and if we had just been more clinical we would have won ! If we play like that for the remainder of the season we should be ok but Scharner has been fairly poor of late and is a concern for me !Caldwell back in the team :silly: :silly:
very unlucky tonite, deserved something out the game
He is cover for Ramis simple as ! He has been off key the last couple of games though, I don’t think many could deny that !and ramis has been superman throughout :lol: :dry:
Scharner for me was indeed our weakest link tonight and constantly had me squirming in my seat ! I had a gut feeling that he would have a hand in any goals that we conceded and unfortunately I wasn’t wrong ! Great performance tonight and if we had just been more clinical we would have won ! If we play like that for the remainder of the season we should be ok but Scharner has been fairly poor of late and is a concern for me !scharner did get turned for the goal but gomez also put a lazy leg out before he shot didn’t expect anything tonight but we didn’t get spanked and a bit of luck could of got something out of the game but we didn’t and we move on 3 points at west ham
Sharner is our best centre half.I’m sorry but if you think he is a better than Alcaraz then the only person who is clueless is yourself !!!!!!!!!!!
Scharner for me was indeed our weakest link tonight and constantly had me squirming in my seat ! I had a gut feeling that he would have a hand in any goals that we conceded and unfortunately I wasn’t wrong ! Great performance tonight and if we had just been more clinical we would have won ! If we play like that for the remainder of the season we should be ok but Scharner has been fairly poor of late and is a concern for me !
scharner did get turned for the goal but gomez also put a lazy leg out before he shot didn’t expect anything tonight but we didn’t get spanked and a bit of luck could of got something out of the game but we didn’t and we move on 3 points at west ham[/quote]
A result tonight was a bonus. We haven’t f*cked our goal difference up and have given ourselves a huge confidence boost ahead of both the final and the run-in by competing with them.
Win at West Ham on Saturday and we climb out the bottom 3 with a winnable game in hand and Villa having to go to Old Trafford on Monday night.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
